An agreement saying 'independent contractor' does not settle the worker's tax classification. CRA examines the actual working relationship. A genuine contractor operates a business; an employee works under an employment relationship with deductions and employer obligations.
Getting this wrong can leave a business owing CPP, EI, penalties and interest, and can cause other legal problems.
What factors does CRA consider?
Relevant facts include who controls the work, who supplies equipment, who risks losing money, whether the worker can profit by managing the work, whether subcontracting is permitted and how integrated the person is into the business.
No single factor is decisive. Industry practices and the real terms of engagement matter.
Example: two graphic designers
Designer A uses their own equipment, prices projects, takes several clients, hires subcontractors and bears the cost of mistakes. Those facts can support independent business status.
Designer B works fixed company hours under a manager, uses company equipment, performs only the company's work and is paid a guaranteed wage. Those facts can support employee status even if invoices are issued monthly.
What tax changes if a worker is an employee?
An employer generally withholds income tax and employee CPP/EI where applicable and pays employer portions. Employees usually receive T4 slips; independent contractors normally report their own business income and eligible expenses.
The contractor may have GST/HST obligations once registration requirements apply. Charging HST on an invoice alone does not prove that worker status is correct.
What happens on reassessment?
If CRA determines a purported contractor was an employee, the hiring business can face responsibility for unremitted payroll deductions and employer portions. Separate provincial employment-law obligations may also arise.
Keep contemporaneous evidence such as contracts, invoices, project instructions, tools, service terms and the ability to serve other customers.
When should you request a ruling?
Where status is genuinely uncertain, CRA has a process for a CPP/EI ruling. Requesting clarification early can prevent years of incorrectly handled payroll.
Reassess workers if their duties or control arrangements change over time.
Sources and further reading
General educational content only. Verify current CRA and provincial guidance before acting.